Join Now And Get Premium Puzzles Delivered To Your Door!
Get Started

Introducing The 4 Puzzle Plan!

Unwind with more puzzles and no shipping delays

 

The easiest way to experience fun, new and challenging puzzles

Unlimited access to thousands of puzzles tailored to your level

Get unlimited access to thousands of puzzles tailored to your level

With Completing The Puzzle you get instant access to the largest catalog of rentable puzzles in the U.S. With over 1,258 top-rated puzzles across over 50+ brands. Rent a new one every time. New puzzles are added weekly!

Renting saves you a ton of money

Save even more money

Buying puzzles can get expensive. The average puzzle costs upwards of $22 before shipping. Renting allows you to try new, challenging puzzles for less than $11 per puzzle! This translates to savings of up to $44 every month! Plus you get FREE SHIPPING on every order.

It's the most sustainable way to puzzle

It's the most sustainable way to puzzle

Less puzzles collecting dust and being thrown away is a very good thing! With renting, puzzles are shipped in eco-friendly, custom, reusable packaging. In addition to being nearly waste-free, a portion of every Completing The Puzzle sale goes to planting trees (8,102 and counting)!

More puzzle time, on your schedule

More puzzle time, on your schedule

You'll get 4 puzzles sent to you once a month so the fun never stops. Once you're done, send your puzzles back and another four will ship the next month!  If you ever finish your puzzles before the end of the month and want even more puzzles, you can always accelerate your next shipment. Returns are easy, everything you need is included. You never have to worry about searching for your next puzzle when you're done. Maximum fun, minimum hassle.

No more closet full of puzzles

No more closet full of puzzles

Tired of storing all those games and puzzles? Say goodbye to that! Renting makes puzzling easy and conveniently saves space. Get more puzzle time without all the storage headaches.

Discover Puzzle Paradise: All Your Favorite Brands And New You'll Adore!

Discover Puzzle Paradise: All Your Favorite Brands And New You'll Adore!

No dollar store puzzles here. Every piece gives you that satisfying snap and the pictures are awesome.

We carry everything from established brands like Dowdle, Pomegranate, and New York Puzzle Co to boutique brands like eeBoo, Art & Fable, and Pezel.

How It Works

1
Choose Your Plan
2
Complete Checkout
3
Set Puzzle Preferences
4
Enjoy Your Puzzle Pack!
Try Completing the Puzzle

Select Your Plan

497 Reviews

What you'll get:
- Premium puzzles based on preferences
- Pre-printed return label for easy returns
- Laminated photo to help you complete it
- Digital picture of your puzzle
- Reusable return shipping container

MOST POPULAR
RENT & SAVE $30. LEARN MORE

Monthly Plan

$44

Try us out:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Cancel or pause anytime

CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee
MOST POPULAR
RENT & SAVE $93. LEARN MORE

3-Month Plan

$126 $132

For the frequent puzzler:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Save $6 every three months
Cancel or pause anytime

CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee
BEST VALUE
RENT & SAVE $204. LEARN MORE

6-Month Plan

$240 $264

For puzzlers who want to save big:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Save $26 every six months
Cancel or pause anytime

Select Your T-Shirt Size:
(T-Shirts are Unisex)
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee

Most Popular Questions

Q: How much time is spent waiting between puzzle shipments?
A: Each puzzle pack is shipped monthly on your renewal date. If you want to accelerate your puzzle pack, you can contact us, adjust your renewal date and ship your next pack the next business day.

Q: How do you handle missing pieces?
A: We always start with new or verified puzzles. We have a system that helps reduce the frequency but it does happen. Nine times out of Ten, someone's spouse is hiding the piece 😈

Thousands Of Happy Puzzlers And Counting

Join thousands completing puzzles every week with our best-selling subscription. Get access to 1,258+ puzzles and join in on the fun now!

"This is not only an easy to use service but it's also environmentally friendly. From the packaging to reusing puzzles, I love being able to puzzle morally. It's also cheaper than buying puzzles every month! You can even put some of your favorite puzzles on your wishlist. This is a fantastic service and it really is worth using. Easy to use, environmentally conscious and not expensive!"

- Lydia M.

"I absolutely love puzzles, the variety I get is fun and the puzzles look great! I have done over 10 puzzles and just love it. I recommend any who loves to puzzle to get this. Never missing pieces and its just cheaper than buying puzzles and storing them."

- Jake F.

"I LOVE this company. I love to puzzle and do not have any more room to buy more. Completing the puzzle is perfect for me. I can do a puzzle in a couple days and have a new one by the end of hte week to start. Such a great conecept and they are great to work with. Puzzles are great quality and I would recommend this to anyone!"

- Kellie S.

JOIN NOW

Frequently Asked Questions

We've solved these puzzling questions

Q: What puzzle brands do you carry?
A: We carry over 51 of the highest quality puzzle brands and many of your favorites. Our brands include: Dowdle, Cobble Hill, Galison, Area Ware, Eurographics, Eeboo, Masterpieces, Mudpuppy, Tania Wicks, Art & Fable and many more!

Q: How many puzzles can I choose from?
A: Over 1,258 across different premium puzzle brands. Through our suppliers we have early access to new, fun puzzles. We keep track of every order to make sure you get a new, surprising puzzle every time.

Q: Can I change my subscription after I start?
A: You can change your membership to get harder or easier puzzles anytime. Log into your account and change your subscription whenever you want.

Q: How do you sanitize the puzzles?
A: We have a proprietary system that uses a series of fans, UVA light and a MERV13 filter to remove contaminates and sanitize everything.

Q: Is there really a Money-Back Guarantee?
A: Yes! While we are confident you will receive a puzzle you love, if you are unhappy we offer a 100% no questions asked Money Back Guarantee. If you complete your account setup after purchase, you need to set your skill level, puzzle preferences and add 10 or more puzzles to your wishlist to unlock the full benefit. We're not happy unless you are happy. We have thousands of happy customers and are willing to bet on it.

Q: What happens if I take longer than 30 days to complete my puzzles?
A: When you back your puzzle pack, we'll ship your next pack when USPS scans the return puzzles. If you find that 4 puzzles is too many, you can pause or downgrade at anytime!

All Rights Reserved, Completing the Puzzle, LLC ® 2024
Privacy Policy

Configuring Your Plan...