Join now and get FREE shipping on all orders!
Join Now

Change the Way You Puzzle

The easiest way to experience fun, new, and challenging puzzles. Take our quiz and receive unique puzzles picked for you

Featured on:

How it Works

Start solving your next puzzle

Select Your Level

Are you up for a challenge? Pick from either beginner, intermediate or expert difficulty levels... you can switch anytime!

Pick your preferences

You set your Puzzle Preferences. A surprise puzzle is picked based on your preferences

Get Puzzling

Solve your puzzle at your own pace. Team up with your family and friends to speed it up

Repeat

Ship back your puzzle with our prepaid label and we'll ship out your next puzzle

What's In The Box?

Everything you need for hassle-free, puzzling fun: a surprise puzzle based on your preferences, pre-printed return label for easy returns from your home and a laminated photo to help you complete the puzzle.

What to Expect

The New Way to Puzzle: Premium, Stress Free, Unlimited Puzzle Rental

Premium Puzzles

We ship high quality puzzles that are durable and fit together perfectly with that "satisfying snap" - no dollar store puzzles here.

Not only do we ship the big brands like New York Puzzle Co and Dowdle, we ship smaller, newer brands like Art and Fable and eeBoo.

Sustainable Experience


Rather than purchase puzzles and have them sit on your shelf only to be thrown out, our puzzles are sanitized and reused to get maximum lifespan out of each one.

In addition to being nearly waste free, a portion of every sale goes to plant a tree. We've planted over 7,904 trees!

Fun Delivered to Your Door

The included prepaid return label ships out USPS. Simply apply the return label and place the package in your mailbox when you finish the puzzle. The original shipping bag doubles as the return packaging. Maximum fun, minimum hassle.

STAY IN THE KNOW!

Sign up for email updates about our puzzles and sales

Notes and Quotes

The reviews are in: Everyone loves our subscription, see what they're saying...

"We spend less time watching tv and more quality time together, thanks!
- Rachel R.
"I love this puzzle subscription!"
-Leslie B.
"We love getting a surprise in the mail! These puzzles are so much fun to do together"
- Machado Family
"I love a challenge. These puzzles keep my brain sharp!"
- Gary H
"Great service you are providing. It’s hard to find good quality puzzles but you have! We like this so much we may frame it... Thanks again!"
- Teresa M.

Puzzling Questions

How much does this cost?

Membership starts at $25 per month.

You can cancel at anytime. Fair warning... puzzling is addicting! Once you start, you'll quickly find yourself connecting "one more piece" just before bedtime.

Will you buy my existing puzzles?

Yes! Fill out this form and we'll reach out to confirm shipping details. Once we receive and verify there are no missing pieces, we'll credit your account $7 off the next month's subscription. See the FAQs for more information.

How are the puzzles cleaned?

We have a proprietary system that uses a series of fans, UVA light and a MERV13 filter to remove contaminates and sanitize everything.

How many puzzles do you have?

1000s across different premium puzzle brands. Through our suppliers we have early access to new, fun puzzles. We keep track of every order to make sure you get a new, surprising puzzle every time.

Can I change my subscription after I start?

You can change your membership to get harder or easier puzzles anytime. Log into your account and change your subscription whenever you want.

How quickly do you ship?

We ship and return USPS first class. Each new order is shipped out the next day (except Sundays). Your returned puzzle is shipped out the following business day before 5pm CST. You'll receive email notifications every step of the way.

You found the missing piece!

Let's play a game and we'll reward you with a coupon

Play Game

Find the missing piece:

Tap the missing piece

Yay!