Puzzle Buy Back Program

We'll buy your unused puzzles!

We'll buy your puzzles that are just sitting around your house!

How does it work?

1. You must be a Completing the Puzzle customer first (sign up here)
2. Fill out this form here
3. Submit up to 6 puzzles. We'll review your puzzles for quality and verify all the pieces are returned
4. Receive a future credit on your account for $7 off each month for every verified puzzle. You are responsible for shipping costs. Not valid with other offers. Only valid on active subscriptions.

What information do I need?

1. Puzzle name
2. Puzzle brand
3. Piece count
4. Link to puzzle image

What kind of puzzles can I submit?

We currently accept Art & Fable, BetterCo., Cobble Hill, Dowdle, eeBoo, Eurographics, Galison, New York Puzzle Company, and Pomegranate puzzles. Puzzles can be done before, but should be in "like-new" condition (no pulled tabs, broken pieces, etc.).

Where can I submit my puzzles?

Log into your account and click the "fill out the form" button below the puzzle buy back section.