🇺🇸 Celebrate the 4th of July!  Save $10 Off Multi-Month Gift Cards 🇺🇸
Get Started
🇺🇸 Celebrate Memorial Day 🇺🇸 Get a FREE Mini puzzle with any new multi-month subscription!

Endless Puzzles, Unlimited Fun

Experience the first-ever puzzle rental subscription with 1,321 high quality puzzles delivered right to your door

Get Started

Over 630,000 puzzles shipped!

Less Screen Time, More Me Time

Say goodbye to one time use puzzles crowding closets and collecting dust and hello to endless puzzle variety and entertainment.

The Largest Catalog Of Rentable Puzzles, Tailored To You

With 1,321+ unique high quality puzzles to choose from, you'll never run out of new challenges. Create a wishlist of your favorites, select your preferences and enjoy a personalized puzzle experience, every month. Experience puzzles across various themes, difficulty levels and brands.

Get Started

Puzzles You Love, Guaranteed

You'll think it's Christmas everytime you receive a puzzle package. Take our quiz and set your wishlist, we'll send you puzzles you're guaranteed to love.

Sustainable

Rather than purchase puzzles and have them sit on your shelf only to be thrown out, our puzzles are sanitized and reused to get maximum lifespan out of each one.

In addition to being nearly waste free, a portion of every sale goes to plant a tree. We've planted over 8,102 trees!

Premium Puzzle Experience

No dollar store puzzles here. Every piece gives you that satisfying snap and the pictures are awesome.

We carry everything from established brands like Dowdle, Pomegranate, and New York Puzzle Co to boutique brands like eeBoo, Art & Fable, and BetterCo.

Hassle-Free Delivery & Returns

Your first puzzles arrives within 3 business days complete with a welcome packet. Including coasters, a personalized letter and fun stickers.

Each delivery features a premium puzzle with a detailed legend. When you're done simply affix the prepaid return label, drop it in your mailbox or at the post office, and get ready for for your next puzzle adventure.


Get Started

What You Get

Everything you need for hassle-free, puzzling fun:

  • A premium puzzle based on your preferences and wishlist
  • Pre-printed return label for easy returns from your home
  • Laminated photo to help you complete the puzzle
  • Digital picture of your puzzle
  • Reusable return shipping bag

How It Works

1
Choose Your Plan
2
Complete Checkout
3
Set Puzzle Preferences
4
Enjoy Your Puzzle Pack!
Try Completing the Puzzle

Select Your Plan

What you'll get:
- Premium puzzles based on preferences
- Pre-printed return label for easy returns
- Laminated photo to help you complete it
- Digital picture of your puzzle
- Reusable return shipping container

MOST POPULAR
RENT & SAVE $30. LEARN MORE

Monthly Plan

$44

Try us out:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Cancel or pause anytime

CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee
MOST POPULAR
RENT & SAVE $93. LEARN MORE

3-Month Plan

$126 $132

For the frequent puzzler:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Save $6 with a 3 month plan
Cancel or pause anytime

CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee
SECRET FLASH SALE
BEST VALUE
RENT & SAVE $204. LEARN MORE

6-Month Plan

$240 $264

For puzzlers who want to save big:

4 premium puzzles per month
Sustainable packaging
FREE puzzle swag
FREE shipping both ways
Save $24 with a 6 month plan
Cancel or pause anytime

Select Your T-Shirt Size:
(T-Shirts are Unisex)
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
CONTINUE TO CHECKOUT
100% Money-Back Guarantee

Puzzling Questions

How much does this cost?

Membership starts at $28 per month.

You can cancel at anytime. Fair warning... puzzling is addicting! Once you start, you'll quickly find yourself connecting "one more piece" just before bedtime.

Will you buy my existing puzzles?

Yes! Fill out this form and we'll reach out to confirm shipping details. Once we receive and verify there are no missing pieces, we'll credit your account $7 off the next month's subscription. See the FAQs for more information.

How are the puzzles cleaned?

We have a proprietary system that uses a series of fans, UVA light and a MERV13 filter to remove contaminates and sanitize everything.

How many puzzles do you have?

1000s across different premium puzzle brands. Through our suppliers we have early access to new, fun puzzles. We keep track of every order to make sure you get a new, surprising puzzle every time.

Can I change my subscription after I start?

You can change your membership to get harder or easier puzzles anytime. Log into your account and change your subscription whenever you want.

How quickly do you ship?

We ship and return USPS first class. Each new order is shipped out the next business day. Your returned puzzle is also shipped out the following business day. You'll receive email notifications every step of the way.

Puzzle for a Better You

Spend less time in front of screens and more quality time with your family, friends or by yourself.

Couple puzzling together

Bond with your puzzle partner

Cinque Terre puzzle

Travel somewhere exotic

Wine and puzzling on a table

Relax and pair with your perfect beverage

Woman with dog in her lap puzzling. Dog curiously looks at puzzle

Keep your brain sharp

Mother and twin daughters puzzling together

Connect with your family

Young toddler happily puzzling

Improve problem solving skills

Get Started

4.89 out of 5 (verified reviews)

The reviews are in: Everyone loves our subscription, see what they're saying...

Best Subscription Ever!

I love, love love this subscription. I have completed over 10 puzzles in six months. We are always looking forward to our next puzzle. I got my husband (who use to hate puzzles) to actually enjoy putting a puzzle together.

-Veronica S Ybarra
Why I go to the mail box

I really love my subscription. It is fun to do with my 5 year old grandson, spouse, and by myself. I really enjoy the variety of puzzles with fun photos. I am glad I can get new puzzles and not fill my house with them when done. Better than thrift store because of quality and no missing pieces.

-Amy Cook
Best decision if your a puzzler!

Love, love, love this service! Buying puzzles can get expensive and this makes it so affordable. I complete puzzles within a day or two so having this rental service is

-Jennifer Tetley
#1 Puzzle Service! LOVE!

I LOVE doing puzzles!! This is the best subscription I have found by far for three big reasons
1. Unlimited puzzles a month. I do about 1-2 thousand-piece puzzles a week, so I love that Completing the Puzzle does not limit how many puzzles they will send you each month it is completely based on your pace!
2. Diverse selection. I get so excited when I get a new puzzle because I never know what is in store. Some of my favorite puzzles I have gotten have been ones I would have never selected on my own (so fun)!
3. Great customer service. Their packaging is clear, easy to follow, and all-inclusive, but if you get confused or have any questions they are fast to respond and eager to help.

-Corinne Pellows
Great service!

My daughter and I are avid puzzlers. After doing all of the puzzles we have at home several times, as well as those of our neighbors, we decided to try Completing the Puzzle. What a fun way to try new puzzles and not have to figure out what to do with them after they are complete! We finished our first puzzle 2 days after it arrived and quickly realized we needed to upgrade to 2 puzzles at a time. Upgrading was easy! We are now on our second and third puzzles. Thanks for keeping us busy!

-Mindy McNeill