Pick Your Perfect Puzzle Plan

Experience the first-ever puzzle rental subscription with high quality puzzles delivered right to your door. Begin your puzzling journey today.

Select Your Plan

1 Puzzle Unlimited
$27 / Month
MOST POPULAR
2 Puzzle Unlimited
$48 / Month
BEST VALUE
4 Puzzles Monthly
$40 / Month
Puzzles per Month
1-3 average
2-8 average
4
Cost Per Puzzle
$17 on average
$11 on average
Always $10
Shipping Schedule
Your next puzzle ships when your previous one makes it back to us
Your next puzzle ships when USPS scans your previous puzzle
4 puzzles monthly on your anniversary date
Best For
Casual puzzlers who want a hassle free solution to save space
Speedy puzzlers who want an endless stream of puzzles
Avid puzzlers who want consistent puzzles
Endless Access to 1,326+ Puzzles
Flexibility To Swap Plans and Pause
Free Returns
Earn Prizes For Solving Puzzles
Access to Advanced Puzzles (1500+pc)
Never Be Without A Puzzle (accelerate your next puzzle)

4.89 out of 5 (verified reviews)

The reviews are in: Everyone loves our subscription, see what they're saying...

As Seen In

"Completing The Puzzle is creating a sustainable solution for puzzling!"

"A unique service offering unlimited puzzle rentals across the United States."

"Endless entertainment with hassle-free puzzle rentals."

Get Started

Frequently Asked Questions

    • How many puzzles can I get per month?

      You can complete as many puzzles as you like! Most subscribers finish 2-3 puzzles per month.

    • What if I lose a piece?

      Accidents happen! We take care to provide a great experience for everyone, this includes every puzzle having all their pieces. If a puzzle is returned with a piece missing, we waive fees for the first occurrence. Each additional puzzle returned missing a piece is $5. We will retire and recycle incomplete puzzles.

    • Can I buy a puzzle if I really love it?

      Of course! Many members love the puzzles we stock and we're happy to sell them. Members get a discount and prices vary per puzzle.

    • How do you clean the puzzles?

      We have a proprietary system that uses a series of fans, UVA light and a MERV13 filter to remove contaminates and sanitize everything.

Get Started

Copyright © 2024 Completing the Puzzle. All rights reserved.

How You Save

Average cost of a premium puzzle

$16

Average shipping cost

$10

4 premium puzzles

$64

Shipping

$10

Total cost when buying

$74

Renting with us saves $34 per month
when you sign up for a 6-month plan and you....

🏡 Declutter Your Space, Not Your Passion

🧩 Get Access To 1,252+ Puzzles

🌎 Puzzle With A Purpose

Close and Take Me To the Savings

Configuring Your Plan...

How You Save

Average cost of a premium puzzle

$16

Average shipping cost

$10

4 premium puzzles

$64

Shipping

$10

Total cost when buying

$74

Renting with us saves $34 per month
when you sign up for a 6-month plan and you....

🏡 Declutter Your Space, Not Your Passion

🧩 Get Access To 1,252+ Puzzles

🌎 Puzzle With A Purpose

Close and Take Me To the Savings

Select Your Savings

Starter (Monthly)

$30/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Try us out. Most flexible option to pay as you go. Cancel anytime.
Select

Puzzler (3-Months)

$29/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save with upfront billing. Pay $87 today for 3 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select

Pro Puzzler (6-Months)

$28/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save with upfront billing. Pay $168 today for 6 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select

Select Your Savings

Starter (Monthly)

$50/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Try us out. Most flexible option to pay as you go. Cancel anytime.
Select

Puzzler (3-Months)

$48/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save $6 with upfront billing. Pay $144 today for 3 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select

Pro Puzzler (6-Months)

$47/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save $18 with upfront billing. Pay $282 today for 6 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select

Select Your Savings

Starter (Monthly)

$44/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Try us out. Most flexible option to pay as you go. Cancel anytime.
Select

Puzzler (3-Months)

$42/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save $6 with upfront billing. Pay $126 today for 3 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select

Pro Puzzler (6-Months)

$40/mo.
FREE SHIPPING AND RETURNS
Save $24 with upfront billing. Pay $240 today for 6 months of puzzling fun. Cancel anytime.
Select