Previously, we rounded up a list of our picks for the best new jigsaw puzzles released in 2025. We heard from many of you that you wanted to see puzzles that were available to rent through our catalog. And we're all about delivering puzzle joy, so we've put together the top puzzles that were newly added to our rental catalog in 2025. These were the puzzles that you, our community, loved and added to your wishlists the most.
So here are the Top 10 puzzles that were new to our catalog this year, picked by you!
We find that puzzle lovers are often also book lovers, so it doesn't surprise us that this book shop scene was a big hit. This was the puzzle most added to our subscribers' wishlists by far, with 2,988 of you giving it a heart. Boardwalk Puzzles is a brand that we were excited to have join our catalog this year with 4 of their designs. Looks like we'll have to add more with how popular their puzzles have been with you all!
Another Boardwalk puzzle tops the list with this glitzy scene capturing the iconic theaters and other landmarks on the world-famous Hollywood Boulevard. This puzzle was added to 2,034 of your wishlists. Take a close look at the details and you might spot some moments from your favorite classic movies!
This picturesque scene is a crowd pleaser with its bright colors and relaxing vibes. Who wouldn't want to vacation here? This tranquil puzzle was added to our subscribers' wishlists 1,481 times. Eurographics brand has been part of our rental catalog since the early days and we continue to add new designs from them since they're beautiful and well-loved by you!
Puzzlefolk is a smaller, lesser known brand, so we're glad to see so many of you liking their puzzles - 1,378 of you, in fact! This image is quirky, colorful and perfect for the vagabonds. We love dreaming of camping in different terrains, climates and seasons as we piece this together.
This mystical, fantastical image was created by Aimee Stewart, a wildly popular puzzle artist. 1,294 of you love the rainbow of colors, the steampunk elements, and being transported into scenes of wonder and exploration through this puzzle.
This breathtaking nature scene is another favorite among 1,285 of you. It evokes a lot of emotion with a mother bear guiding her cubs, the dreamy mist of early morning, and the golden light that the artist Mark Keathley has so skillfully captured. This is a challenging puzzle for sure, but worth it to take in the full scene at the end.
Clementoni is not a new brand (they've been making puzzles since the '70s), but it was new to our catalog this year. Based in Italy, they are known for their high quality pieces and beautiful, scenic images. This vibrant image of one of Spain's most famous sites captured 1,245 of your hearts.
We're sensing a theme of wanderlust in our Top 10! This puzzle gives a sense of possibilities (where to next?) and a history of memorable adventures. We love the worn leather, aged metal clasps and nostalgic feel. 1,240 members echoed our sentiments and added this beauty to their wishlists.
It wouldn't be Venice without its iconic canals and gondolas! This scene perfectly captures the character of the city with its weathered brick and stone, bridges and waterways. This puzzle was added to your wishlists 1,229 times and cemented Clementoni as the most popular brand amongst our subscribers this year.
Proving the enduring pull of Venice, this puzzle rounds out our Top 10 with a sweeping view of the Grand Canal at sunset. From the domed structure of the Santa Maria della Salute to the colorful sky, golden lights reflecting in the water, and deep blue darkening the sky and water, 1,184 of you felt the magic of this puzzle and added it to your wishlists.